Jump to content
Peter_

Suggestions for small home system - ~4 megapixel cameras

Recommended Posts

Hey everyone, first off the info here has been extremely helpful. Have read posts here for ~ the last month.

 

So here's what I would like help with. Currently I have 2 foscam bullet cameras (FI8904W) that I know have a limited life. I am recording the videostreams to a Synology NAS running Surveillance Station 5, which so far has worked out very well. BTW, this setup is for a home with pretty decent nighttime lighting (streetlights, under the eve lighting, flood lights that illuminate trees, etc).

 

What I am looking for is a reasonably priced PoE megapixel camera (dome or bullet) that I could use in addition or as a replacement for my system. I plan to stream video using a picostation HP (wireless N). Here's what I'd ideally like to find in a camera:

 

-PoE

-1+ megapixel resolution

-Outdoor (must be weatherproof - but I live in Arizona so snow/rain not an issue; i.e. no heater)

-Good night vision (~ 40 feet at night - see video above)

-Motion detection

-On board storage

-Price range ~500 each (plus or minus ~200) [i'd like to buy several]

 

Here's what the yard illumination looks like at night (

)

and during the day (

)

 

I'm a student so price is a challenge, I'd love to grab a couple Mobotix but obviously that's not going to happen. I'm setting this system up for my parents, and as a fun project. I know some professionals don't like to share their knowledge, but I'm trying to use this as a learning experience too, so any help is appreciated.

 

In my persistent googling I've written down these choices:

-Toshiba IKWR12A

-Vivotek FD8361

-Sanyo HD3300/3500

-Sony SNCDH210TB

-ACti KCM-7211

-ACti TCM-7811 (looks like great night vision)

-ACti KCM-7111

-Vivotek FE8171V (new fisheye - good way to use less numbers of cameras)

 

 

Thanks in advance!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey everyone, first off the info here has been extremely helpful. Have read posts here for ~ the last month.

 

So here's what I would like help with. Currently I have 2 foscam bullet cameras (FI8904W) that I know have a limited life. I am recording the videostreams to a Synology NAS running Surveillance Station 5, which so far has worked out very well. BTW, this setup is for a home with pretty decent nighttime lighting (streetlights, under the eve lighting, flood lights that illuminate trees, etc).

 

What I am looking for is a reasonably priced PoE megapixel camera (dome or bullet) that I could use in addition or as a replacement for my system. I plan to stream video using a picostation HP (wireless N). Here's what I'd ideally like to find in a camera:

 

-PoE

-1+ megapixel resolution

-Outdoor (must be weatherproof - but I live in Arizona so snow/rain not an issue; i.e. no heater)

-Good night vision (~ 40 feet at night - see video above)

-Motion detection

-On board storage

-Price range ~500 each (plus or minus ~200) [i'd like to buy several]

 

Here's what the yard illumination looks like at night (

)

and during the day (

)

 

I'm a student so price is a challenge, I'd love to grab a couple Mobotix but obviously that's not going to happen. I'm setting this system up for my parents, and as a fun project. I know some professionals don't like to share their knowledge, but I'm trying to use this as a learning experience too, so any help is appreciated.

 

In my persistent googling I've written down these choices:

-Toshiba IKWR12A

-Vivotek FD8361

-Sanyo HD3300/3500

-Sony SNCDH210TB

-ACti KCM-7211

-ACti TCM-7811 (looks like great night vision)

-ACti KCM-7111

-Vivotek FE8171V (new fisheye - good way to use less numbers of cameras)

Thanks in advance!

 

From your list !

Sanyo + comp based NVR or

Sanyo + Standalone NVR

I would never compare Sanyo to ACTI or Vivotek.

if u can afforded

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FWIW

Was not impressed with the quality of the Acti, cheap though...

Vivotek I've yet to see a great night pic at a decent shutter speed...

No experience with the others

 

I'm playing with an Arecont 3135 which is not bad although quirky, a little better night performance than my Axis P3344. With minor lighting pole light with 3 small bulbs I can get usable pics around 1/20s. You are obviously at a slow shutter speed as there is a bit of blur.

 

Axis has great firmware, support and is a quality product. If you shop around you sometimes can pick them up on ebay around 4-500. Plus they do audio.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So I'm hearing Sanyo and Axis? Without IR leds will I be able to get a decent shutter speed at night? The axis cameras are very nice, but only a few are outdoor rated out of the box. The axis 212 says it only works up to 104 deg F. In AZ a hot day can get up to 110 deg F+.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So I'm hearing Sanyo and Axis? Without IR leds will I be able to get a decent shutter speed at night? The axis cameras are very nice, but only a few are outdoor rated out of the box. The axis 212 says it only works up to 104 deg F. In AZ a hot day can get up to 110 deg F+.

You'll need ICR to do IR. The 212 is not a day night camera and has a poor lux rating. FYI Axis specs their cameras at 1/6s I think. You can see some examples of the P1344 at

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=25728

 

I have no experience with Sanyo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have dealt with all of the above cameras over the years both Sanyo and Sony are very good..

 

I am the Australian Distributor of SONY cameras and the Exmor Chipset is awesome in low light but no for every budget..

 

I was a ACTi dealer but with a 20% failure rate I would not touch them with a 10 foot pole. Needless to say I ght compared to SONYdropped them quickly.

 

Also if you want a decent low cost camera then Messoa is a fair camera and nice clean images but average at low light.

 

Also for a NVR then use Excaq or QNAP, I am dealers for both and have great success with them both

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have to agree with the aussie, Messoa is a good camera but leaves allot tobe desired at night and the SONY cameras well I agree you want good quality then you have to pay for it..

 

The Exmor CMOS is as good as any CCD camera I have seen in Low Light...

 

Exacq and QNAP are good but Exacq is the pick for me...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×